The move to trade Guentzel was made by then-Penguins general manager Kyle Dubas, which for many within the organization was something that has come out of left field. Dubas sent Guentzel to Carolina, a move the forward insists he did not see coming. If the drama did not stop there, the captain of the Penguins,
Sidney Crosby, voiced his dissatisfaction with the move publicly to an extent that called the intentions of management into question and sent shockwaves around the league.